Ping irons are not your usual golf clubs. They look different, they are made different, they feel different. And it should be fair that right from the beginning I confess my deep admiration to Ping, being a former I3+ player for a few years until Mizuno irons came into my life (MP37.
The S59 come in TWO versions, and this should be always remembered when you are considering them: the S59 Blade and the S59 Tour, the easiest and FASTEST way to tell one from the other, is very simple: the Tour has ferrules, the Blades DONT. After a closer inspection, you will see that the Tour model has a smoother finish, but otherwise they are exactly the same. However, during this review I´ll be focusing on the S59 Blades, the "Unpolished/ferruless" model. You are considering a move towards this better-player irons? Consider the following observations first:
1.- They are BLADES. I don't care what your handicap is: your SKILL level must be quite good in order to take advantage of the S59s. The sweet spot is very small (compared to cavity backs), so any wrong-doing will penalize you with distance AND direction.
2.- They DO offer some forgiveness, though. As far as "blades" go, I´ve never played one as forgiving as this one. The small cavity and rail on the back do place the COG a bit lower and behind the face, so this may be the ideal irons to begin your move toward pure blades (but I'm quite sure you will not get rid of them soon). To me, they are the most forgiving blades I´ve played, but please note the word BLADE here, ok?
3.- They look like nothing else out there. Typical Pings. No fancy stuff, no cute gadgetry, only pure form and function. In the case of the S59, they look as if they were cut in half: the sole is shiny and polished, the top-line looks unfinished and raw. To me, this is a BEAUTIFUL combination! No ferrule means another unusual sight for a golf iron, but hey: who needs it when you are hitting the ball SO good?
4.- They are Pings: For those of you who have never played Pings, let me tell you something: quality is unmatched, craftsmanship is phenomenal. Of course you MUST custom fit them to you before purchasing, and Ping has the most comprehensive, simple and effective custom fitting system in the world. They may be a bit more expensive, but they are worth every penny. Guarantee is renowned for its history of customer satisfaction.
5.- Excellent control. If you have good enough game for this sticks, then start getting used to your new ability to play shots like never before. The trajectory is mid on the long irons, and mid-high with the mid and short irons. You can work the ball with ease (I play a mild fade)and the ball becomes a pin-seeking monster. Irons shafts seem to work a bit better if you prefer a tighter dispersion, but the stock TFC 100 graphite shafts are a bit longer and offer excellent shock absorption properties.
6.- Mid ball flight. As with most blades, lower shots should be expected, but that in no way means your approaches will be hard. The short irons deliver a nice semi-high trajectory with loads of spin to keep those hard green in check. The main difference between the S59 and the I3+ (a much more forgiving and high-launching iron) is the effort you must use to get the ball airborne: with the I3+ is automatic, but the S59 require commitment and desire to get the ball moving up, shot after shot.
7.- Not forged, but great feel. Soft enough to let you enjoy every good ball strike, but firm enough to let you know how you struck the ball every time. Remember the sweet-spot is smaller than a Cavity back, so mis-hits WILL hurt a bit. Skulled/thin shots lose considerable distance, but dont feel as painful as a "regular" blade. I say they are the best feeling Pings ever.
8.- Excellent but limited shaft options. With only 3 iron and 3 grahpite custom options, I think some golfers will not be very pleased nor impressed, However, I must admit that both the TFC 100 graphite and theZ-Z65 steel shafts are well above average, up to par with the best Rifles or True Tempers.
9.- They demand above average skill. The thin sole handles digging very well, but will not let you get lazy for a second. While I did not find them to be particularly long (I demoed a 3-PW red-dot set with graphite R flex shafts), when you let your swing loose you can produce some really long shots with the 4-5 irons, as they are very powerful sticks. Perfect shots demand precise striking, and when this does not happen, you will most likely find your ball in trouble. Distance penalization is a trademark od the S59 on mis-hits, but then again, this clubs are meant for players who can hit the small sweet-spot 99% of the time.
10.- A shotmakers delight. Fades, draws, punches, knockdowns, you name it: it is in the S59´s arsenal. While not as versatile as their I3+ cousin, when you compare the S59 against OTHER blades, the difference is huge. They offer much more mercy than Pure blades in many ways, so many of you could begin experimenting with shot shaping much easier with these Pings easier than with any other blade.
IN all, I loved the S59, because they are formidable performers that play as a blade but with a bit of forgiveness, something almost impossible to even think before. The short irons work wonder around the greens, absolute scoring machines from inside 150 yards. The Long irons are not the easiest to hit but you can always change/mix them with more forgiving G2´s or I3+. The Spin out of the 7-8-9 and PW is among the BEST I´ve ever seen.
If you can consistently shoot 12 over par or better, and make 50% GIR per round, I´d say you are ready to try them.
Excellent clubs!